For BBQ enthusiasts, finding the perfect mustard to elevate their grilling experience is essential. The right mustard can make all the difference in adding that extra kick of flavor to your favorite dishes. When it comes to choosing the best mustard for your BBQ creations, there are several key factors to consider. From the flavor profile to the texture, consistency, ingredients, and heat source, each element plays a crucial role in determining the overall quality of the mustard. Whether you prefer a spicy, sweet, or tangy flavor, a smooth or grainy texture, or a pourable or thick consistency, there are options out there to suit every palate. Additionally, the choice between natural and artificial ingredients, as well as the heat source of vinegar or mustard seeds, can further impact the taste and quality of the mustard you select.
Lillie’s Q Carolina Gold Barbeque Sauce: Authentic Southern BBQ Flavor
Lillie’s Q - Gold Barbeque Sauce, Gourmet Carolina Sauce, Tangy BBQ Sauc... -- $19.17(Amazon)
Gold Barbeque Sauce Gallon | Lillie's Q -- $41.99(Amazon)
Zero Sugar Gold Barbeque Sauce, Gourmet Carolina Sauce, Tangy BBQ Sauce ... -- $12.36(Amazon)
Lillie’s Q - Gold Barbeque Sauce, Gourmet Carolina Sauce, Tangy BBQ Sauc... -- $41.99(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
Lillie’s Q Carolina Gold Barbeque Sauce is a meticulously crafted condiment that embodies the rich tradition of South Carolina BBQ. With its tangy mustard base and a perfect blend of sweetness, it's designed to elevate the flavor of your favorite BBQ dishes, from pulled pork to grilled chicken. Made with premium, gluten-free ingredients and without high fructose corn syrup or MSG, it offers a gourmet, authentic experience. The sauce's unique story, tied to Lillie herself, adds a personal touch to its appeal, making it more than just a condiment but a piece of Southern culinary history.
Who It's For
This sauce is ideal for BBQ enthusiasts who appreciate the depth of traditional flavors and are looking for a high-quality, versatile sauce for a range of dishes. It's especially suited for those who enjoy a tangy kick with a hint of sweetness in their BBQ. However, it may not be the best fit for individuals on strict low-sugar diets due to its sugar content.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Crafted to honor South Carolina BBQ traditions with a tangy, mustard-base | ❌ Contains sugar, which may not suit those on low-sugar diets |
| ✅ Made with premium, gluten-free ingredients, no high fructose corn syrup, no MSG | ❌ Price may be higher compared to standard BBQ sauces |
| ✅ Versatile use on chicken, pork, or hot links for an authentic BBQ experience | ❌ Specific taste profile that might not appeal to everyone |
Stubb’s Legendary Hickory Bourbon Bar-B-Q Sauce: Rich Flavor BBQ Sauce
Stubbs Bar-B-Q Sauce, Legendary, Hickory Bourbon - 18 oz -- $6.99(The Kansas City BBQ Store)
Stubb's Original Legendary Bar-B-Q Sauce -- $10.49(BJ's Wholesale Club)
Stubb's Bar-B-Q Sauce, Legendary, Original - 36 oz -- $4.98(Amazon)
Stubbs Hickory Bourbon Barbecue Sauce, 18 Ounce -- 6 per case. -- $49.13(Walmart - shopGourmet.com)
Why We Picked It
Stubb’s Legendary Hickory Bourbon Bar-B-Q Sauce is a standout choice for BBQ enthusiasts looking to elevate their dishes with a unique and rich flavor profile. The combination of hickory smoke and bourbon infuses meats with a deep, complex taste that's hard to replicate with other sauces. Its versatility makes it suitable for a wide range of BBQ dishes, from ribs to chicken, enhancing the overall dining experience with its finger-licking, hickory pit flavor.
Who It's For
This sauce is perfect for BBQ lovers and home cooks who enjoy experimenting with bold flavors and are looking to bring a touch of Texas-style BBQ to their meals. It's especially suited for those who appreciate the depth that bourbon can add to their dishes. However, it may not be the best fit for individuals with gluten sensitivities or those who prefer their BBQ sauce less sweet.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Unique blend of hickory smoke and bourbon for complex flavor | ❌ May be too sweet for some palates |
| ✅ Versatile for a variety of meats including ribs, chicken, and pork | ❌ Contains gluten, not suitable for gluten-sensitive individuals |
| ✅ No high-fructose corn syrup, focusing on quality ingredients | ❌ Price may be higher compared to other BBQ sauces |
Bone Suckin’ Mustard: Award-Winning Gourmet Mustard
Bone Suckin Mustard 2 Count -- $22.99(Amazon)
Bone Suckin' Mustard, 12 Ounce, 12 Count -- $95.03(Amazon)
Bone Suckin Mustard, Sweet Spicy - 12 oz -- $8.95(All Things Barbecue)
Why We Picked It
Bone Suckin’ Mustard is a versatile and flavorful addition to any kitchen, winning 1st place at the Great American Barbecue Contest in Kansas City and being recognized as a National Champion by the World Mustard Museum. Its unique blend of honey, spices, and mustard offers a perfect balance of sweetness and spice, making it suitable for a wide range of dishes from ham biscuits to hot dogs. Its gluten-free, Kosher Pareve, and dairy-free certification, along with the absence of high fructose corn syrup, ensures it meets various dietary needs and preferences. Made in the USA, this mustard is a high-quality product that enhances any meal.
Who It's For
Bone Suckin’ Mustard is ideal for food enthusiasts looking for a versatile sauce to elevate their cooking, whether it's for marinating, dipping, or spreading. It's perfect for those who appreciate gourmet, award-winning flavors and are seeking healthier condiment options without high fructose corn syrup. However, due to its honey content, it might not be suitable for strict vegans.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ 1st Place Winner at the Great American Barbecue Contest in Kansas City | ❌ Honey content may not be suitable for strict vegans |
| ✅ Gluten Free, Kosher Certified Pareve, Dairy Free, No High Fructose Corn Syrup | ❌ Price may be considered high for a condiment |
| ✅ Versatile use in cooking - from marinades to spreads | ❌ Specific taste may not appeal to all |
French’s Classic Yellow Mustard: Classic Mustard for Every Occasion
French's Classic Yellow Mustard - 2 pack, 30 oz bottles -- $6.48(Sam's Club)
French's Classic Yellow Mustard Dispensing Pouch with Fitment -- $15.3(Amazon)
French's Mustard, Classic Yellow - 500 pack, 0.25 oz packets -- $18.95(GoFoodservice.com)
Why We Picked It
French's Classic Yellow Mustard is a quintessential condiment that brings a tangy and creamy flavor to a wide array of dishes. Its versatility and all-natural ingredients make it a perfect choice for both home kitchens and food service establishments. With options ranging from convenient squeeze bottles to bulk dispensing pouches, it caters to various needs while ensuring quality and taste. The absence of gluten, dairy, high fructose corn syrup, and artificial colors or flavors, coupled with its calorie-free composition, appeals to health-conscious consumers and those with dietary restrictions.
Who It's For
Ideal for families, restaurants, and food service providers looking for a classic mustard flavor to enhance their dishes without overpowering them. It's also perfect for those seeking a healthier condiment option without sacrificing taste. However, it might not be the best fit for individuals or chefs looking for a mustard with a stronger, more adventurous flavor profile.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Tangy, creamy traditional mustard flavor that pairs well with a variety of dishes | ❌ Some might find the flavor too mild for more adventurous dishes |
| ✅ Convenient and versatile packaging options, including squeeze bottles and dispensing pouches | ❌ Bulk packaging may not be ideal for small households |
| ✅ Made with feel-good ingredients, free from gluten, dairy, and high fructose corn syrup | ❌ Limited flavor variety compared to more exotic mustards |
Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 Mustard: Boozy BBQ Mustard Delight
Brown Sugar Bourbon Mustard 10 oz -- $9.98(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 Mustard is a unique condiment that combines the rich, smoky flavor of Jack Daniel’s Whiskey with the tangy kick of mustard. This product is perfect for those looking to elevate their BBQ and cooking experience with a touch of boozy sophistication. Its infusion with Jack Daniel’s Whiskey not only adds a distinctive flavor but also brings a novel twist to traditional mustard, making it a standout choice for culinary enthusiasts.
Who It's For
This mustard is ideal for adults who appreciate the nuanced flavors that whiskey can bring to food. It's perfect for BBQ lovers, gourmet cooks looking for something new to try in their recipes, and Jack Daniel’s fans eager to explore the brand's influence in culinary products. However, it might not be suitable for those avoiding alcohol, even in minimal amounts, or for families looking for condiments that are kid-friendly.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Infused with the classic taste of Jack Daniel’s Whiskey, adding depth to its flavor | ❌ Alcohol content, although minimal, might be a concern for some consumers |
| ✅ Versatile use in BBQ, burgers, glazes for ham or salmon, enhancing a variety of dishes | ❌ May not be suitable for children or individuals avoiding alcohol for personal or health reasons |
| ✅ Unique gourmet product for those looking to elevate their cooking and BBQ experience | ❌ Priced at $9.98 for a 10 oz bottle, it might be considered expensive compared to regular mustards |
Plochman’s Original Stone Ground Mustard: Best Rustic Flavor Enhancer
Plochman's Original Stone Ground Mustard -- $41.81(my happy pantry)
Why We Picked It
Plochman’s Original Stone Ground Mustard is selected for its unique preparation method and flavor profile. The stone-ground mustard seeds provide a distinct taste and texture that enhances a variety of dishes, particularly in the realm of barbecues and hearty sauces.
Who It's For
This mustard is ideal for culinary enthusiasts who appreciate a more rustic and robust condiment in their cooking. It's especially suited for those who enjoy crafting their own BBQ rubs and sauces or who like to add a punch of flavor to sandwiches and vinaigrettes. However, it may not be the best choice for individuals who prefer their condiments to be smooth and creamy.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Robust stone-ground mustard flavor | ❌ Grainy texture may not suit all preferences |
| ✅ Ideal for BBQ rubs and hearty sauces | ❌ May be too intense for mild palates |
| ✅ Adds texture and depth to dishes | ❌ Not as versatile as smoother mustards for certain recipes |
Trader Joe’s Organic Yellow Mustard: Best Organic Mustard for Budget Shoppers
Trader Joe's Organic Yellow Mustard, 9 oz -- $5.45(Amazon)
2 Pack Trader Joe's Organic Yellow Mustard -- $11.65(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
Trader Joe’s Organic Yellow Mustard is selected for its commitment to organic ingredients, making it a healthier option for those who enjoy classic American condiments. Its affordability also ensures that health-conscious consumers don't have to break the bank to enjoy a quality product. Perfect for BBQs and everyday use, this mustard provides the familiar tangy taste that complements a variety of dishes.
Who It's For
This mustard is ideal for health-conscious individuals and families who prefer organic products without artificial additives. It's also great for budget-minded shoppers looking for organic options. While it may not satisfy those seeking gourmet flavors, it's a solid choice for anyone who wants a classic mustard taste in their pantry.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Certified organic ingredients | ❌ May lack gourmet flavor complexity |
| ✅ Affordable price point | ❌ Limited to one classic flavor |
| ✅ Suitable for a variety of dishes | ❌ Packaging is basic without premium features |
Annie’s Organic Dijon Mustard: Best Organic Gourmet Mustard
Annie's Organic Dijon Mustard, Gluten Free, 9 oz. -- $8(Amazon)
Annie's Mustard, Organic, Dijon - 9 oz -- $5.59(Swanson Health Products)
Annie's Naturals Organic Dijon Mustard, 9 oz -- $7.96(Amazon)
Annie's Mustard, Organic, Dijon - 9 oz -- $5.59(Swanson Health Products)
Annie's Organic Dijon Mustard, 9 oz (Pack of 2) -- $16(Amazon)
Annies Organic Dijon Mustard, 9 Ounce -- 12 per case. -- $77.86(Walmart - shopGourmet.com)
Why We Picked It
Annie’s Organic Dijon Mustard is a standout choice for those seeking a tangy, gourmet taste in their condiments, without compromising on health and environmental standards. Its organic certification ensures that it's made with high-quality, natural ingredients, catering to the growing demand for organic products. The gluten-free aspect broadens its appeal, making it accessible to those with dietary restrictions. Additionally, its commitment to no artificial flavors, synthetic colors, or preservatives aligns with a more health-conscious consumer base.
Who It's For
This product is best suited for culinary enthusiasts who prefer a sharper, more robust flavor in their dishes, particularly in BBQs. It's also ideal for health-conscious individuals or those with dietary restrictions, such as gluten intolerance, looking for organic, clean-label condiments. However, it may not be the best fit for those who prefer milder flavors or are sensitive to the strong taste of Dijon mustard.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Certified organic ingredients for a cleaner, more sustainable choice | ❌ Stronger flavor may not suit all palates, especially in dishes with milder flavors |
| ✅ Gluten-free, catering to dietary needs without compromising taste | ❌ Price point may be higher compared to non-organic alternatives |
| ✅ No artificial flavors, synthetic colors, or preservatives for a healthier option | ❌ Limited availability in certain regions or stores |
Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce: Best Sweet and Tangy Dipping Sauce
Sweet Baby Ray's Dipping Sauce, Honey Mustard - 14 fl oz -- $2.29(Target)
Sweet Baby Ray's Savory Sauce Bundle -1 ct Sweet Baby Ray's Original 18 ... -- $13.29(Amazon)
Sweet Baby Ray's Gourmet Honey Mustard Sauce 64 fl oz. -- $25.99(Amazon)
Sweet Baby Ray's Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce (Pack of 5) 14Oz Bundle of ... -- $34.35(Amazon)
Sweet Baby Ray's Dipping Sauce, Honey Mustard 14 fl oz Pack of 4 -- $24.14(Groceryeshop)
Why We Picked It
Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce is a delightful blend that captures the essence of traditional BBQ flavors with a unique twist. The combination of sweet honey and tangy mustard creates a versatile sauce that enhances the taste of a variety of dishes, from BBQ wings to chicken tenders. Its thicker consistency makes it an excellent choice for dipping, ensuring a robust flavor with every bite.
Who It's For
This sauce is ideal for BBQ enthusiasts who enjoy a sweet and tangy flavor profile in their condiments. It's perfect for those who love to dip their meats, especially chicken wings and tenders, or want to add a burst of flavor to their burgers and brats. However, it might not be the best fit for individuals looking for a thinner, more pourable sauce for marinating or dressing salads.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Perfect blend of honey sweetness and mustard tang | ❌ Thicker sauce may not be suitable for all BBQ applications |
| ✅ Thick consistency ideal for dipping | ❌ May not be preferred by those who enjoy a more subtle mustard flavor |
| ✅ Versatile use with BBQ wings, tenders, burgers, and more | ❌ Not ideal for those looking for a pourable sauce for marinating |
Heinz Yellow Mustard: Classic Condiment for Everyday Meals
Heinz Yellow Mustard (8 oz bottle) -- $1.67(Amazon)
Heinz 100% Natural Yellow Mustard, 14 Ounce (Pack of 3) by Heinz -- $26.7(Grocery.com Store)
Heinz Yellow Mustard 12.75oz, Size: 12.75 oz -- $4.99(Walmart - Motherland Groceries LLC)
Why We Picked It
Heinz Yellow Mustard is a staple condiment that brings a classic, familiar taste to any meal, especially BBQs. Its reputation for quality and the perfect balance of flavor and tang makes it a reliable choice for enhancing a variety of dishes. With its 100% natural ingredients, including top-grade mustard seeds, it offers a guilt-free addition to your meals, containing 0 calories per serving. The variety of sizes available, from an 8 oz bottle to a 14 oz pack of 3, ensures that whether you're a light user or need to stock up for many meals, there's an option for you.
Who It's For
This mustard is ideal for those who appreciate a classic and traditional flavor in their condiments. It's perfect for families looking to stock their pantry with a versatile and widely-acceptable option for BBQs, sandwiches, and more. However, it might not be the best fit for those seeking a unique or gourmet mustard experience, as its flavor profile is very standard.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Made with 100% natural ingredients, ensuring a healthier choice | ❌ Very standard flavor that might not appeal to those seeking unique or gourmet options |
| ✅ Contains 0 calories per serving, making it a guilt-free addition to any meal | ❌ Price point for the 14 Ounce (Pack of 3) may seem high compared to single bottles |
| ✅ Offers the thick and rich taste expected from a reputable brand like Heinz | ❌ Limited to yellow mustard, lacking variety in flavors for those looking to experiment |
Thanks for checking out our top mustard picks! If you have any more questions or need further recommendations, feel free to reach out. Happy grilling!